Car Insurance Reviews
Real customers share their experiences from working with independent insurance agents to get matched to the best auto insurance policies.


Cara Carlone is a licensed P&C agent with 20 years of experience. She has her P&C license in RI and TX and holds CPCU, API, and AINS designations.

When shopping for a new car insurance policy or when you're ready to switch coverage to a different carrier, it can be wise to do some research first. Comparing this year's top car insurance companies and customer reviews, along with official ratings, can be an effective way to do this. Consumer ratings on auto insurance providers from reliable independent sources are another great way to learn more about a provider.
You can look for car insurance ratings and reviews in auto magazines and compare top car insurance companies through official rating agencies like AM Best and the Better Business Bureau (BBB). However, working with a local independent insurance agent can be by far the most efficient way to find quality, affordable auto insurance in your area. These agents have access to multiple local car insurance companies and are free to shop and compare quotes and policy options for you.
Read on to discover what real customers are saying about the experience of buying car insurance with the help of independent insurance agents.
What Real Customers Are Saying About Independent Insurance Agents
When you’re looking for reviews of auto insurance coverage, it’s not just the coverage but the personal experience with an agent that makes a difference. Auto insurance customers who have reviewed their experience with local independent insurance agents are impressed with their agent’s knowledge and the quality of coverage. Here are the personal accounts of 10 satisfied insurance customers.
Read these reviews to see what they have to say:
Glick Insurance
“My experience with this agency was great! Cindy and Amanda are always ready to greet you with their positive attitude. They are knowledgeable in any questions you may have. You do an awesome job ladies!”
Sherman
Fallon Insurance Agency
“...Through accidents, whether mine or not, I've never had any problems and all of my questions through the years have been answered promptly and accurately. I'm fortunate to have started as a customer with them and I will continue...”
Christina
Texan Insurance
“Stefan DeShazo helped me out with my insurance needs. He was professional, respectful, knowledgeable about insurance, and he guided me through the entire process...”
Xavier
Byrnes Agency, Inc.
“We have been with [the] agency for at least fifteen years for both home and auto insurance and have had great service from day one. I would recommend Byrnes Agency to family, friends, or anyone who asks.”
Jeff
Clear Choice Insurance Services
“Nicole was fantastic! She rescued us right before our closing and got us a great product. She was so responsive and quick and got everything done super quickly. Highly, highly recommend!”
Meghan
Bernier Insurance Inc.
“We just got our first travel trailer and needed insurance on it and Nichole got back to us right away. She got us quotes and explained the different policies and helped us make an informed decision. Very easy.”
Richard
Lewis A. Clark Insurance Agency, LLC
“I always look forward to speaking with my agent. Everyone is always courteous and professional and I love the way they follow up with me. I would recommend them to anyone.”
Michelle
Sonoran National Insurance Group
“We have always had stellar service from Cathy and Sonoran National. She gives great feedback and information and helps us to get the best insurance for our situation. We fully trust Cathy with managing our home, auto and umbrella policies.”
Teresa
Independent Insurance Agents Are Here to Help You Find the Best Car Insurance
When it comes to finding the right car insurance policy, no one's better equipped to help than a local independent insurance agent. These agents have access to multiple car insurance carriers in your area, so they're free to shop and compare policies and rates for you to find the best deal.
Your agent knows where to look to find not only affordable coverage, but a trustworthy and reliable carrier known to deliver on its coverage promises with a good track record for paying out claims. And down the road, your agent will still be there to help file car insurance claims for you and update your coverage when necessary.